Kin selection and altruism in honey bees by bob battaglia. Kin altruism can look like altruistic behaviour whose evolution is driven by kin selection. If two organisms are closely related they will share many genes and therefore want to protect these genes in the other organism, showing altruistic behavior. A biological theory stating that a gene that causes an organism to exhibit behavior detrimental to its survival will increase in frequency in a. Pdf twelve misunderstandings of kin selection by richard. In spite of these successes, support for the role of. Kin selection theory explains social behavior at the level of the individual rather than at the level of the group or the species. Why is our psychology so geared towards others language and empathy.
Kin selection, female preferences and the evolution of leks. List four ways in which having offspring is energetically costly for female primates. Kin selection is a fundamentally important process that affects the evolution of social behaviours. In many of these colonies, the queen is the only female that reproduces. Group selection, kin selection, altruism and cooperation. Large colonies of certain ants, bees and wasps are other popular examples of kin selection at work. This is a pdf file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for. Because of the issues listed above, what appears to be the most important limiting factor that. The models of soft selection, hard selection, kin selection and group selection can be represented as variations of a common general model that expresses the total gene frequency change, itself a. It is based on the concept of inclusive fitness, which is made up of individual survival and reproduction direct fitness and any impact that an individual. Kin selection definition is a theory of natural selection which states that a usually altruistic behavior or attribute that lowers the fitness of a particular individual is selected for if it increases the probability of survival and reproduction of related kin who possess some or.
The major obstacle to constructive discussion between us really arises from the. Hamiltons theory of kin selection is the bestknown framework for understanding the evolution of social behavior but has long been a source of controversy in evolutionary biology. What is the difference between kin selection, and group. Twelve misunderstandings of kin selection dawkins 1979. Kin selection also extends beyond the relationship between parents and their offspring. The controversy of kin selection, group selection and altruism. Kin selection is the evolutionary strategy that favours the reproductive success of an organisms relatives, even at a cost to the organisms own survival and reproduction.
Celebrating prezi s teacher community for teacher appreciation week. Kin selection is a type of natural selection in which an individual attempts to ensure the survival of its own genes by protecting closely related individuals first. In this commentary, we discuss previous studies that explored the link between kin selection and patterns of variation within the genome. Kin selection definition is a theory of natural selection which states that a usually altruistic behavior or attribute that lowers the fitness of a particular individual is selected for if it increases the probability of survival and reproduction of related kin who possess some or all of the same genes as the altruistic individual.
Strassmann social insects so dominate many terrestrial habitats wilson 1990 that they can hardly es cape the attention of biologists, but even if they were rare, they would. Kin selection and social insects university of washington. According to ks theory, altruism is based on a model of individual selection in which the gene for altruism is the selected unit dawkins 1989. Kin selection and social insects social insects provide the most surprising predictions and satisfying tests of kin selection david c. This theory states that people are more likely to help blood relatives in difficult situations because this increases the odds that their genes will be transmitted to subsequent generations.
Kin selection is the theory put forward by the biologist w. Kin selection, female preferences and the evolution of. Eusocial behavior in honey bees bob battaglia and sierra wood general background references honey bees apis mellifera are social insects. In this view, hamiltons rule is basically correct for describing kin selection, and most deviations from it are due to. Wynneedwards and konrad lorenz argued that the behavior of animals could affect their survival and reproduction as groups, speaking for instance of actions for the good of the species. Kin selection says that cooperation and helpfulness is determined by how related one is to another. Kin selection, genomics and casteantagonistic pleiotropy. Kin selection is the idea that because genes influence behavior, and because an animal that helps its relatives helps to spread genes likely identical to its own, animals will evolve to favor kin. Extensions of kin selection theory parent offspring conflict sibling conflict extraordinary sociality. Cultural group selection, coevolutionary processes and largescale. Kin selection is a way of understanding allele frequency change as a consequence of the actions and interactions among individuals who share alleles by recent common descent ie, kin. The closer the relationship between the beneficiaries and the altruist and. This may be because the equivalence thesis merely shows the equivalence of two statistical formalisms without saying anything about causality. This paper lists and refutes 12 of the commonest misunderstandings, for example.
Abstract hamiltons theory of kin selection is much misunderstood. The fact that most cases of extreme reproductive altruism are found in hymenoptera might be due to other features of this group, for example the unusually high. Nevertheless, the idea that relatedness among individuals can drive the evolution of altruism has emerged as a central paradigm in evolutionary biology. Research focus kin selection is the key to altruism kevin r.
Kin selection is the evolutionary strategy that favours the reproductive success of an organisms. The first is by increasing the likelihood that body. Kin selection and evolution of behavior flashcards quizlet. Kin selection kin selection is a cognitive and behavioral adaptation, and as such a result of natural selection. Kin selection, a type of natural selection that considers the role relatives play when evaluating the genetic fitness of a given individual. Inclusive fitness models have implicitly assumed that seltion is weak, whereas exactpopulation genetic models place no constraints on the strength of selection. Sexual reproduction implies that parents are genetically not identical to their offspring only half of the alleles are from a. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. However, kin selection and group selection are not distinct processes, and the effects of multilevel selection are already accounted for in hamiltons rule, rbc, provided that an expanded definition of r, not requiring hamiltons original assumption of direct genealogical relatedness, is used, as proposed by e. Kin selection definition otherwise known as inclusive fitness theory, kin selection refers to the theory that people have evolved to favor others who are genetically related to them. Hamiltons theory of kin selection is much misunderstood. Kin and kind again about kin selection posted on march 10, 2012 by artem novozhilov now the details of the story nowak et al.
For the evolution of altruistic traits by kin selection, see equation in the pdf file is always. Several examples are presented showing that qualitatively new behavior has emerged from the exact models. Kin selection suggests that relatedness is the dominant force in the evolution of social actions 2,4 costs and bene. As with group selection, it is a consequence of the properties of groups that cause allele frequency change. Throngs of sterile female workers handle nearly every other task in the colony, from scouting and collecting food, to building the nest or hive, and raising the young. However, i show that a time average of the evolutionary response to kin selection under blending coincides exactly with that derived under mendelian considerations. Kin selection is an instance of inclusive fitness, which combines the number of offspring produced with the number an individual can ensure the production of by supporting others, such as siblings. Hamilton found that altruism can spread with the help of kin selection. Since this synergistic effect does not depend on the interactants being related, it is best viewed as something distinct from kin selection. Suppose that a rare gene for altruism is present in an individual. Kin selection in the discussion of natural selection, the emphasis was on how natural selection works on individuals to favor the more fit and disfavor the less fit in a population. Contrasting views of kin selection assessed sciencedaily. Kin selection theory, also known as inclusive fitness theory, has been the subject of much debate and misunderstanding. Hamiltons theory of kin selection is the bestknown framework for understanding the 6 evolution of social behaviour, but has long been a source of controversy in evolutionary biology.
It facilitates the development of altruistic behaviour when the energy invested, or the risk incurred, by an individual is compensated in excess by the benefits ensuing to relatives. Maynard smiths communication raises a good many more questions than i can attempt to answer here. When charles darwin published on the origin of species in 1859, he proposed a revolutionary new way of thinking about the natural world. Kin selection definition of kin selection by the free. The emphasis was on the survival mortality selection. Wilson 2, charles goodnight 3, doug taylor 4, yaneer baryam 5, marcus a. The emphasis was on the survival mortality selection, mating success sexual selection, or family size fecundity selection of individuals. Kin selection is changing our views of imprinting 12 and maternalfetus diseases in humans 12. Wynneedwards1,2 has argued persuasively for the importance of behaviour in regulating the density of animal populations, and has suggested that since such behaviour favours the survival of the. Altruistic behaviors are also common between close family members. Pdf soft selection, hard selection, kin selection, and.
All species members share the majority of their genes, so selection should favour universal. Relatedness and social behaviors in cercopithecus solatus pdf. Natural selection works on individuals and not on groups or ecosystems. Kin selection favors traits that increase indirect fitness direct fitness indirect fitness inclusive fitness hamiltonos rule rb c 0 natural selection favors altrusistic acts when indirect fitness benefits to the receiver, reduced by the coefficient of relatedness, exceeds costs to the altruist wd hamilton 1964 individual reproduction. This hypothesis holds that the many males unsuccessful in obtaining matings at leks join these aggregations because it increases the mating success of their reproducing. The development of a theory of kin selection has proceeded along two lines. Kin selection assumes no colonylevel effects 2,4,8 kin selection models include colonylevel effects, sometimes implicitly and sometimes explicitly 3,9,11 kin selection is incompatible with traitgroup selection thinking 2,4 the two frameworks are complementary and fully compatible 1214 relatedness r and kin selection only apply. Kin selection has particular relevance to grounddwelling squirrels and, as a consequence, they have been called the social hymenopterans of the mammalian world.
Note that kin selection is not the same thing as group selection, where natural selection is believed to act on the group as a whole. Clearly kin selection is a strong, vibrant theory that is. Instead, kin selection, an extension of natural selection theory that explains such behaviors, has become the cornerstone of behavioral ecology and sociobiology. Kin selection is a special, complex kind of natural selection, as opposed to individual selection. Natural selection, kin selection and group selection. Keywords cooperation, altruism, group selection, inclusive fitness. Change in gene frequency under kin selection is the sum of two components. Past considerations of kin selection have assumed a dyadic fitness exchange relationship between altruist and recipient. Ratnieks2,4 1laboratory of ecological and evolutionary dynamics, department of biological and environmental sciences, university of helsinki, helsinki, 00014, finland 2wissenschaftskolleg zu berlin, institute for advanced study, berlin, 14193, germany. I distinguish individual and populationcentred approaches to drawing such a distinction, and i proceed. Kin selection, group selection, and the varieties of. By eliminating the gene from the theory of kin selection, i clarify its role in the theory of social adaptation. The magnificent beauty and diversity of nature isnt a static creation, darwin insisted, but the result of hundreds of millions of years of impossibly slow and small changes called evolution at the heart of darwins theory is the process of natural selection. Group selection, and in a related sense kin selection 4243444546474849 50 515253545568, have been extensively examined to explain, e.
He starts with a brief description of population growth noting the importance of. Start studying kin selection and evolution of behavior. Kin selection refers to changes in gene frequency across generations that are driven at least in part by interactions between related individuals. Group selection refers to the idea that alleles can become fixed or spread in a population because of the benefits they bestow on groups, regardless of the fitness of individuals within that group. A recent critique of the theory by nowak, tarnita, and wilson sparked a new round of debate, which shows no signs of abating. Kin selection is an instance of inclusive fitness, which combines the number of offspring produced with the number an individual. Kin selection is the evolutionary altruism that selects for those behaviors that increase the inclusive fitness of the donor. Hamiltons inclusive fitness theory 14 16 the term kin selection theory was coined by john. Let r denote likelihood that it is also in another individual, given as a probability between 0 and 1. Sexual selection seems to be very resource consuming much effort spend in. Kin selection definition of kin selection by merriamwebster.
The cost of honesty further remarks on the handicap principle, journal of theoretical biology 67. In a recent paper, traulsen and nowak use a multilevel selection model to show that cooperation can be favored by group selection in finite populations traulsen a, nowak m 2006 proc natl acad sci usa 103. The logic of the theory is that a gene can propagate itself through two routes. Kin selection under blending inheritance sciencedirect. Interacting organisms may have an evolutionary incentive to help each other or at least to hurt each other less if they share genes, and the magnitude of this incentive should increase with the degree of relatedness between them. Group selection is a proposed mechanism of evolution in which natural selection acts at the level of the group, instead of at the more conventional level of the individual early authors such as v. The theory claims that the frequency of the gene for altruism increases in the population as a result of the altruistic behaviour, even though it decreases the reproduction of the. The closer the relation between the people, the greater the likelihood that help will be given. An altruistic behavior is one in which an individual the donor performs an action that helps another animal the recipient with no apparent advantage to itself.
The genomics revolution now provides the opportunity to test kin selection theory using genomic data. Bioscience since 1964, bioscience has presented readers with timely and authoritative overviews of current research in biology, accompanied by essays and discussion sections on education, public policy, history, and the conceptual underpinnings of the biological sciences. The basics of kin selection theory kin selection theory has. Frank cezusphotographers choicegetty images when charles darwin published on the origin of species in 1859, he proposed a revolutionary new way of thinking about the natural world. A recent critique of the theory by nowak, tarnita, and wilson sparked a new round of debate, which. Dec 17, 2014 kin selection is the idea that because genes influence behavior, and because an animal that helps its relatives helps to spread genes likely identical to its own, animals will evolve to favor kin.
Multilevel and kin selection in a connected world nature. Proceedings of the national academy of sciences 103. Kinselection theory explains social behavior at the level of the individual rather than at the level of the group or the species. Wynneedwards1,2 has argued persuasively for the importance of behaviour in regulating the density of animal populations, and has suggested. Kin selection is the key to altruism sciencedirect. The authors challenge the view that kin selection may be an appropriate interpretation of their results and state that group selection is a distinctive process that.
159 417 934 970 1211 1289 891 1351 1593 50 21 1616 278 440 1684 1090 862 393 1102 733 507 684 84 197 1393 1214 285 229 1337 591 97 297 1422